Knicks’ Trade Deadline Dilemma: Backup Center or a Game-Changing 2-Way Wing?

The New York Knicks are at a crossroads halfway through the 2024-25 season, sitting firmly in the third spot in the Eastern Conference. While their starting lineup has shown championship potential, significant issues with bench depth and defensive consistency remain. As the Feb. 6 trade deadline approaches, the Knicks must address these weaknesses if they are to remain true title contenders.

Knicks President Leon Rose made a bold move heading into this season, constructing one of the most talented starting units in franchise history. With Jalen Brunson signed long-term, the defense of OG Anunoby retained, Mikal Bridges acquired through trade, and Karl-Anthony Towns replacing Julius Randle, the team looked poised for a deep playoff run. The additions were aimed at taking the Knicks from playoff hopefuls to legitimate championship contenders.

However, as the season progresses, the Knicks’ reliance on their starting five has exposed significant gaps. Despite ranking in the top five for field goal percentage, three-point shooting, and free-throw efficiency, the team struggles defensively (ranking 15th in defensive rating) and is dead last in bench scoring. With four starters near the top of the league in total minutes played, there are growing concerns about the sustainability of this heavy reliance on the main rotation.

One of the biggest challenges for head coach Tom Thibodeau has been his limited trust in the bench. Without solid scoring options and consistent play, the Knicks’ second unit has often disrupted the team’s rhythm. As a result, there’s growing speculation that the team will need to make a move before the trade deadline to strengthen their bench and add much-needed depth to the frontcourt.

Mitchell Robinson’s return, which is expected by early February, may help alleviate some pressure by giving the Knicks additional support in the frontcourt, possibly reducing Towns’ workload. However, Robinson’s delayed return has left uncertainty about the team’s immediate frontcourt depth, pushing the Knicks to consider trading for another backup center to provide stability.

In addition to frontcourt help, a move for a two-way wing could address the bench’s lack of direction and give Thibodeau more reliable options. A versatile forward would not only add depth but also ease the minutes burden on key players like Mikal Bridges, OG Anunoby, and Josh Hart, who have been heavily relied upon in the starting lineup.

As the trade deadline approaches, the Knicks’ front office faces a pivotal decision: do they focus on bolstering the frontcourt with a backup center or invest in a two-way wing to provide balance and reliability for their second unit? A well-timed, strategic move could be the key to completing their roster and elevating their title aspirations.