When it comes to roster building, New York Giants general manager Joe Schoen emphasizes, “Scared money don’t make money.” However, bold spending, especially with the numerous gaps in the Giants’ roster, requires absolute certainty that the investment is foolproof. This dilemma arises in the context of this year’s draft as Schoen acknowledges the team’s need for a quarterback, and he hasn’t ruled out securing one in the draft.
The challenge lies in the fact that the Giants hold the sixth overall pick, and at least two teams ahead of them, Washington and New England, also need quarterbacks. These teams might be contenders for the top prospects, including Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels, and Drake Maye. The situation becomes more intriguing with the possibility of the Chicago Bears, who possess the first overall pick, either sticking with Justin Fields or opting for a new quarterback.
While it’s too early to predict the actions of these teams, NFL Network insider Ian Rapoport suggests that if the Bears decide to trade out of the first overall pick, they would be seeking a “historic haul.” This demand might be a significant consideration for the Giants, especially given their lack of compensatory picks and the opportunity to address various needs with four picks within the top 70 in the draft order.
Schoen, familiar with moving up for a quarterback from his time with the Buffalo Bills, faces the question of whether the Giants should make such a bold move. The answer seems to hinge on Schoen’s confidence in Maye, Williams, or Daniels being undeniable prospects. Even if he believes in the potential of one of these quarterbacks, there’s the additional factor of whether trading away premium picks is justifiable when the offensive line remains uncertain, and the team lacks a No. 1 receiver.